| Platinum | Romeo's Italian Kitchen |
| Gold | Hoagieville |
| Silver | Rooster Cafe |
| Bronze | Ciao Mambo |
| Top Pick | Acropolis Gyros & Greek Specialties |
| Top Pick | Bob Marshall's Biga Pizza |
| Top Pick | Bridge Pizza |
| Top Pick | Old Chicago Pasta & Pizza |
| Top Pick | Romeos Italian Kitchen |